[WarrENDeatH]

Hey group, in the market for a BMW. Thought I’d ask the group which one you all would recommend from this selection. I am still up in the air.

I've been longing for a better driving experience, something visceral and fun. I'm in a unique health situation and have to be mindful of that as well. I'm also a bigger guy at 6'4, so ease of getting in and out is also a thing. I just miss the 'driving' experience. I have three cars by me that interest me and was curious if anyone had any experience with one, a few, or all of them. Maybe things to avoid or whatever.

2016 BMW 650i (27k miles) 44k (105k new) - USED
2019 X3 M40i(34k miles) 48k (63k new) - CPO
2018 540i xDrive (21k miles) 47.9k (77k new) - CPO

Appreciate your suggestions, owner reviews or potential bewares!

[kring]

I’d go 650, 540, x3. The x3 is tiny and disappointing compared to 5/6 series. Thr x3 trunk/hatch is half the capacity of the others. The V8 puts the i6 to shame, no comparison if you want performance. The i6 is an exceptional engine but it’s not close to the V8. Do not drive the 650 if you are leaning toward the other two for CPO (or other reasons)… the 650 will always be there as a regret, so don’t do that to yourself if you’re likely to need the SUV or practicality of 4 door sedan in the 540.

[WarrENDeatH]

Originally Posted by kring

I’d go 650, 540, x3. The x3 is tiny and disappointing compared to 5/6 series. Thr x3 trunk/hatch is half the capacity of the others. The V8 puts the i6 to shame, no comparison if you want performance. The i6 is an exceptional engine but it’s not close to the V8. Do not drive the 650 if you are leaning toward the other two for CPO (or other reasons)… the 650 will always be there as a regret, so don’t do that to yourself if you’re likely to need the SUV or practicality of 4 door sedan in the 540.

Ironically the 650 sold before the other two (it appears). I’ve just driven the X3 M40. I do like the engine and space a lot for my size. Just wanted a bit more of a visceral driving experience.