[stubey]

For those of us actually trying to buy an e91, please stop thinking you should base your asking price off of BaT.

[Inglewood]

Originally Posted by stubey

For those of us actually trying to buy an e91, please stop thinking you should base your asking price off of BaT.

I think BAT/CAB give a nice benchmark (if nothing more) for those expecting top dollar, as it shows based on the spec and condition of premium examples what the market is willing to pay at this time. That being said, I could never personally deal with the peanut gallery.

[TouringEnthusiast]

Originally Posted by Inglewood

I think BAT/CAB give a nice benchmark (if nothing more) for those expecting top dollar, as it shows based on the spec and condition of premium examples what the market is willing to pay at this time. That being said, I could never personally deal with the peanut gallery.

It seems like a massive headache, given so is marketplace too so far. It's really cool to scroll through and look at everything they have up, but for selling it's just what frustrations you'd rather deal with. I'm just sad I'm too young to have experienced the peak of ebay auctions.

[GA328iT]

Originally Posted by TouringEnthusiast

I'm letting go of my 2009 xdrive e91 6mt. Not 100% on what I want for it, space gray over saddle brown. 128k~ miles. I hate to get rid of it but it's time to move on to other things. It's in okay cosmetic condition, any ideas what they've been going for lately?

Originally Posted by TouringEnthusiast

That's nuts. I threw mine on marketplace for 17.5. I know people are going to try to nickel and dime me, and I'm not super pressed to get rid of it. I'm already having people messaging me telling me I'm nuts. It has some paint wear and such, but after seeing that I'm not sure I'm the crazy one... It's far from perfect, but it's at least (in my opinion) it's a decent spec. But I'm a sucker for the saddle interior.

Originally Posted by TouringEnthusiast

We'll see what I end up getting out of mine. I'd love to get 20k, but I live in a relatively low population density area and don't want to go through the hassle of bring a trailer. I just keep wondering how much more I could get, and if my list price is low. I think it's decently accurate with condition, but Ill be the first to admit I have no clue.

Is yours a 6MT swap? I think the MSport package is a big factor in these top dollar sales. MSport and 6MT are the key factors. Add in RWD, low miles and good spec and that's the pinnacle. The 6MT swap that just went for $29K on BaT had a lot of other stuff going for it in addition to the factory MSport package.

If yours is Space Gray over Saddle, xDrive, non-sport, >120K miles and 6MT swap, I think you are pricing it correctly around $18K - maybe hope to get $16.5. For me, for that price, it'd have to be well sorted and 8 or 9 out of 10 cosmetically in and out. If not, then $17.5K may be pushing it... IMO

[GA328iT]

Originally Posted by stubey

For those of us actually trying to buy an e91, please stop thinking you should base your asking price off of BaT.

... unless you have a RWD MSport factory 6MT with low miles, mechanically sorted and 9/10 cosmetically. If so, then hoping to get 85-90% of BaT price seems reasonable to me.

There are a few run of the mill E91s that sold on BaT for market value (or arguably below market value: $9,300 on 4/22/23 and $7,350 on 4/1/23)....

[angryman11111]

Originally Posted by angryman11111

Hi.

Putting feelers out for a 2011 RWD Msport MT E91. Very low 50K Miles. Black Sapphire Metallic with Black Dakota Leather interior. Convenience, Cold Weather, M Sport, PDC, Manual seats, Xenons. Full maintenance records. New water pump, brakes, and suspension (all OEM parts except for shocks/struts which are Koni Special Active). Original owner. Mostly city driven in NYC.

From when it was new

[TouringEnthusiast]

If yours is Space Gray over Saddle, xDrive, non-sport, >120K miles and 6MT swap, I think you are pricing it correctly around $18K - maybe hope to get $16.5. For me, for that price, it'd have to be well sorted and 8 or 9 out of 10 cosmetically in and out. If not, then $17.5K may be pushing it... IMO[/QUOTE]

That makes me feel a little better. Truthfully I want 15 out of it. I guess it might be a 6mt swap, vin is decoding as an auto and I hadn't thought to look into it before. I was just thrilled to own it. The only reason I'm getting rid of it is to have cash to put back into the house and eventually pick up a new daily that way I'm not putting a ton of miles on the projects.

[Inglewood]

Originally Posted by GA328iT

... unless you have a RWD MSport factory 6MT with low miles, mechanically sorted and 9/10 cosmetically. If so, then hoping to get 85-90% of BaT price seems reasonable to me.

There are a few run of the mill E91s that sold on BaT for market value (or arguably below market value: $9,300 on 4/22/23 and $7,350 on 4/1/23)....

I think BAT has been indicative the e91 market is not paying over 35 now to 38 (at high point during pandemic craze) for e91...the former being the BAT alpine with MPE and single hump last month; the later being one of the last lemans 6MT m sport e91s with low mileage on BAT.

[Thorin]

Originally Posted by GA328iT

The 6MT swap that just went for $29K on BaT had a lot of other stuff going for it in addition to the factory MSport package.

I'm curious as to what those items were that drove it so high. I'm debating whether to "undo" some of the similar changes, or leave it as is.

[GA328iT]

Originally Posted by Thorin

I'm curious as to what those items were that drove it so high. I'm debating whether to "undo" some of the similar changes, or leave it as is.

Who knows what drives bidders on BaT, but the matt blue wrap and black 19" wheels make it look awesome. I think what drove the price so high was the seller - he was very responsive to questions and sounded very knowledgeable and instilled confidence. That coupled with the claim that the swap was done at a BMW dealership perhaps took the sigma of swap out of the equation a bit.

Upgrades/things the car had going for it: Logic7 Sound System, Digital Gauge Cluster, Digital Key, Apple CarPlay, 4K display, backup camera, 19" Style 641 Wheels (and stock style 193s), 6MT swapped at the BMW dealership. Claims to be fully sorted with all major gaskets replaced, cooling system (replaced the coolant expansion tank, radiator, water pump, water pump bolts, accessory drive belts and pullies, and coolant recovery tank hose)...

[NOKO]

My twin! I have one of the other 5 same spec m sport rwd 6 speed wagons! Your's is crazy low mileage and original owner! Really curious what you are asking for it and what you plan on replacing it with! Here are some pics of mine!

Originally Posted by angryman11111

From when it was new

[Inline]

Originally Posted by GA328iT

Who knows what drives bidders on BaT, but the matt blue wrap and black 19" wheels make it look awesome. I think what drove the price so high was the seller - he was very responsive to questions and sounded very knowledgeable and instilled confidence. That coupled with the claim that the swap was done at a BMW dealership perhaps took the sigma of swap out of the equation a bit.

Upgrades/things the car had going for it: Logic7 Sound System, Digital Gauge Cluster, Digital Key, Apple CarPlay, 4K display, backup camera, 19" Style 641 Wheels (and stock style 193s), 6MT swapped at the BMW dealership. Claims to be fully sorted with all major gaskets replaced, cooling system (replaced the coolant expansion tank, radiator, water pump, water pump bolts, accessory drive belts and pullies, and coolant recovery tank hose)...

This was my E91 that was sold on BAT. BAT was a great experience it is just very time consuming to get accepted. This car was swapped by my brother at the dealership. you can see the shop background during the install and the invoice for all the parts from the BMW store. It would use BAT again just need to be very transparent and responsive will the buyers.

[Sendmewagons]

Lower mileage (80k) msport xdrive auto in Alexandria, VA for $18k. White/Oyster. Looks pretty nice. Carfax on the site. Cargurus says Autocheck has 1 accident reported but no damage. Carfax looks clean.

https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/invent...ting=352006819
https://www.miniofalexandria.com/use...U3C54CA543510?

[beardywi]

Originally Posted by Sendmewagons

Lower mileage (80k) msport xdrive auto in Alexandria, VA for $18k. White/Oyster. Looks pretty nice. Carfax on the site. Cargurus says Autocheck has 1 accident reported but no damage. Carfax looks clean.

https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/invent...ting=352006819
https://www.miniofalexandria.com/use...U3C54CA543510?

This has been up for at least a month, right near me here. White just doesn't do it for me or it'd have been long gone!

[angryman11111]

Those wheels are sick on the E91

[rsevn]

Originally Posted by NOKO

My twin! I have one of the other 5 same spec m sport rwd 6 speed wagons! Your's is crazy low mileage and original owner! Really curious what you are asking for it and what you plan on replacing it with! Here are some pics of mine!

damn, every time I see the e91s with 513m wheels makes me want them more and more lol.

[rsevn]

Pasadena, CA | LCI | RWD | Space Grey/Black| 151k miles | $7,500

https://offerup.com/item/detail/67fd...+wagon&cid=5.1 OR their website https://www.altadenaautocenter.com/d...eries/93546788

*edit: I'm near this location if anyone wanted me to check it out for them*

[Pavel_e92]

https://www.e90post.com/forums/showt...3#post30074863

Price lowered to $6500.

[triax37]

Adding my E91 to the For Sale section:

2011 E91 M-Sport l 71k miles l AT l White over Black l $22.5k

https://www.e90post.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2015853

[Andy7777]

I posted a few weeks ago that I was selling my 194m wheels from the wagon I sold earlier, but stupidly I extended my stay on the East Coast with the wheels in Michigan. I'm back together with the wheels and tires, and would like to sell them!

So, here is the FS thread in the classifieds, https://www.e90post.com/forums/showt...9#post30118219

If anyone here contacted me earlier and is still interested, I'll be happy to answer you first.

[beardywi]

Nice example:

https://bringatrailer.com/listing/20...ports-wagon-4/

Low miles and well optioned but a few dings. Curious how BaT determined it has the cold weather package despite a lack of ski bag and heated steering wheel. Don't think CWP just means 'heated seats' but maybe someone knows better than I.

[MMMM6GC]

Mislabeled (typical for fbook) - LCI 328i, black on black, single hump, 128k miles, $9,850

https://www.facebook.com/marketplace...1-b472f7acf4f0